SEEDROUND: Where It All Starts

Smart vs Hard-Working

This is an installment of the ongoing “Fatherpreneurship Series”, which is defined here.

Scientific American has a terrific article about raising kids, titled The Secret of Raising Smart Kids. The article confirms my own instinct that raising your child to be “hard-working” rather than “smart” leads to success in school and life. I encourage you to read the article; here’s one of many interesting insights:

In studies involving several hundred fifth graders published in 1998, for example, Columbia psychologist Claudia M. Mueller and I gave children questions from a nonverbal IQ test. After the first 10 problems, on which most children did fairly well, we praised them. We praised some of them for their intelligence: “Wow … that’s a really good score. You must be smart at this.” We commended others for their effort: “Wow … that’s a really good score. You must have worked really hard.”

We found that intelligence praise encouraged a fixed mind-set more often than did pats on the back for effort. Those congratulated for their intelligence, for example, shied away from a challenging assignment—they wanted an easy one instead—far more often than the kids applauded for their effort. (Most of those lauded for their hard work wanted the difficult problem set from which they would learn.) When we gave everyone hard problems anyway, those praised for being smart became discouraged, doubting their ability. And their scores, even on an easier problem set we gave them afterward, declined as compared with their previous results on equivalent problems. In contrast, students praised for their effort did not lose confidence when faced with the harder questions, and their performance improved markedly on the easier problems that followed.

When hiring, I try to look for “grinders,” people who will work hard to solve problems. In fact, I will take a grinder over a merely smart employee any day. In the article:

In 1972, when I taught a group of elementary and middle school children who displayed helpless behavior in school that a lack of effort (rather than lack of ability) led to their mistakes on math problems, the kids learned to keep trying when the problems got tough.

I find that putting smart people around the table can lead to interesting (and often long discussions), but put together a bunch of hard-workers, well, progress happens. Now when we can find people who are wicked smart and hard working, well, these people we do anything to keep for life.

3 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Great article. What I found most interesting was how failure was perceived in fixed v. growth mind-sets. Fixed mind-sets saw failure as their own lack of ability while growth mind-sets saw failure as a lack of effort. It definitely makes you think about what to emphasize with your kids when discussing their accomplishments and failures.

Dave, the hard part, of course, is figuring out how to instill a strong work ethic in your kid. Let me know if you have the manual for that.

Although I find the article interesting based upon what seems to be a narrow comparison of 2 different mind sets, I must point out that most children I have interacted with are not normally able to be categorized in such a manner in these 2 areas.

Most children are taught to be hard working or to just be “smart”, and while the old adage of “say it long enough and you will start to believe it” does apply here, it does not account for the many other variables that come into play in this article.

For instance, would the same children that were told they must be smart have responded the same way if told they would work hard? I think not as the child’s personal development and outside influences play a larger role in what a child is more inclined to do in addition to positive re-enforcement.

Interesting study none the less…



Leave a comment
  • Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed
  • HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)